| Bob | Sagers, Sr. |
| 2008 |
| Craig | Sanders |
| 2012 |
| Mike | Sanzere |
| 2010 |
| Jerry | Scheve |
| 2022 |
| Paul | Schildmeyer | Leadership Award | 2022 |
| Doug | Schloemer | Holmes | 2017 |
| Ryan | Schrand |
| 2013 |
| Charlie | Shars | Western/Bowling Green/Hawks | 1998 |
| Ken | Shields | Highlands/NKU/ St Thomas | 1998 |
| Tim | Shields | Conner/Thomas More | 2015 |
| Phil | Sinkovich | UC Clermont | 2022 |
| Adrian | Smith | Royals | 1996 |
| George | Smith | UC | 1996 |
| George | Spencer | Washington/Bullets | 1999 |
| Bob | Staak | Xavier/Walter Forest | 2002 |
| Larry | Staverman | Villa/Royals | 1996 |
| Mark | Stein | Flaget Louisville/Xavier/Hawks | 2001 |
| Lois Warburg | Sterwerf |
| 2016 |
| Maurice | Stokes | St Francis/Royals | 1997 |
| George | Stone | Lincoln Grant/Marshal/Stars | 2000 |
| Jeff | Stowers | Simon Kenton/NKU | 2022 |
| Derek | Strong |
| 2012 |
| Joe | Sunderman | LaSalle / Xavier | 2024 |
| Tammy | Svoboda | Princeton/standford | 2022 |
| Pat | Sword |
| 2014 |
| Mike | Sylvester | Moeller/U Dayton | 1998 |
| Wally | Szczerbiak |
| 2010 |
| Dan | Tehan |
| 2011 |
| Tom | Thacker | William Grant/UC | 1996 |
| Gerry | Thelen | Con Cath/Thomas More/Royals | 2002 |
| Steve | Thomas | Roger Bacon/Xavier | 1997 |
| Mel | Thomas |
| 2017 |
| LaSalle | Thompson | Withrow/Texas/Pacers | 1999 |
| Tom | Thompson |
| 2008 |
| Michelle Munoz | Trenz |
| 2015 |
| John | Turner | Newport/Louisville | 1997 |
| Jack | Twyman | UC/Royals | 1996 |
