| Chuck | Machock | St Henry/OSU/UC? Coach | 2000 |
| Chris | Mack | Mt Healthy / Coaching | 2024 |
| Carol | Madsen | Reading/Purdue/Xavier | 2000 |
| Dick | Maile | 2019 | |
| Erik | Martin | 2014 | |
| Kenyon | Martin | 2016 | |
| Mike | Mathis | St Xavier/Purdue | 1998 |
| Glen “Buddy” | Mayborg | 2012 | |
| Walt | McBride | Summitt Country Day/Xavier | 2002 |
| Jim | McCafferty | Xavier/ | 1998 |
| Jane | Meier | Mt St Joe/NKU/ | 2002 |
| Shannon | Minor | 2012 | |
| Kelly Benintendi | Mislen | 2023 | |
| Kelly Benintendi | Mislen | 2023 | |
| Jackie Bearden | Mistler | Dixie | 2018 |
| Kelsey | Michell | Notre Dame | 2023 |
| Steve | Moeller | 2019 | |
| Steve | Moore | 2004 | |
| LaRon | Moore | 2011 | |
| Sydney | Moss | Thomas More | 2023 |
| Donna | Murphy | Newport | 1996 |
| Terry | Nelson | 2015 | |
| Monica | Nieman Zumstein | 2008 | |
| Mike | Nienaber | 2015 | |
| Linda | Norwell | 2023 |
